Guangdong / Shantou, China · Report date: Oct 24, 2026
1 · Side-by-side comparison
Dimension
FiveStar Toys
WANGE Toys
Yida Toys
Risk score
97 / 100
82 / 100
56 / 100
Verdict
Proceed
Proceed
Caution
Registered since
2002 — 24 yrs
2007 — 19 yrs
2021 — 5 yrs
Registered capital
¥20M RMB
Mid-scale
¥1M RMB
Staff (social insurance)
501–1,000
65–82
11–50
Entity type
Manufacturer
Manufacturer
Trading company
Export capability
Domestic-focused
OEM / ODM / OBM
Does not accept export orders
Dishonest-debtor blacklist
None
None
None
Judgment enforcement
None
None
None
Administrative penalties
None
None
None
Operation anomalies
None
None
None
Court cases on record
None found
None found
None found
How to read this: all three have clean legal records. The differences are structural — age, capital, team size and whether they actually export. Those are the gaps an English listing page won't show you, and they change who carries the risk on an overseas order.
2 · Which supplier's records raise the fewest concerns
FiveStar Toys and WANGE Toys are both established manufacturers with no adverse records — the two profiles that raise the fewest concerns for an overseas buyer. Yida Toys is not a scam, but as a 5-year-old trading company with ¥1M capital and no export support, it would leave you carrying the full export and logistics burden. The final decision is yours; this report only surfaces what the records show.
3 · Notes on each supplier
FiveStar Toys Proceed · 97
Largest and most established of the three (24 yrs, ¥20M capital, 500+ staff). Clean records and a clear manufacturing scope. One thing to confirm before ordering: its registered profile is domestic-focused, so verify it has an export team rather than assuming it ships abroad.
WANGE Toys Proceed · 82
A 19-year-old factory with its own "WANGE" trademark and CCC certification, offering OEM/ODM/OBM. Slightly smaller than FiveStar (65–82 staff) but explicitly export-oriented — a strong fit for custom orders with a trial sample first.
Yida Toys Caution · 56
Registered in 2021 with ¥1M capital and 11–50 staff, operating as a trading company that does not accept export orders. Not an automatic red flag — but with this profile you carry the export/logistics work and most of the counterparty risk.
4 · Method & sources
Scope & limitations. Compiled from publicly accessible Chinese business and court registries, then translated and interpreted in English. Findings are marked Confirmed, Consistent, Inconsistent or Not Verified according to the strength of the underlying evidence. This is an informational summary, not procurement or legal advice.